Hey Else,
I appreciated this sentiment:
I try to teach kids that it is the spirit of Christmas that matters...
That's great. It's quite challenging, to wade through the quagmire of commercialism, and convey any meaningful "spirit" to your children... and still we try.
I, too, feel that the form-letter from Santa is a bit over the top.
I was pleasantly surprised, however, when our own local post office replied, under the alias of Santa, to our children's letters. They wrote the letters themselves (as clearly as 4 and 6 year olds can), addressed them to the North Pole, and placed them in our mailbox. Their joy on receiving a reply was uncontainable... a treasured memory to me. I had never considered that the post office or it's volunteers would take it upon themselves to reply.
As a relatively new father (my children are now aged 8 and 6) from a witness background, the events surrounding the progress of their belief in Santa are still fresh on my mind. So as not to bore you with long, syrupy stories of my children (as proud parents often do...) I'll just say this: Most of the elements of your children's belief systems are beyond your control. They will construct their realities from their anecdotal experience, just as you do (amazing, huh? smart buggars...) and your influence will be limited to enabling or discouraging those beliefs, that is all.
Personally, I've chosen not to be the Grinch, and I've been witness to the unfolding of a natural, beautiful process... the adoption and gradual dismissal of their belief in Santa Claus. Looking back, I'm glad Rachel and I chose this course, and I hope our children will be grateful too. I'll try to remember to ask them, someday.
StinkyPantz,
I am going to be straight up with my kids. Knowing the turth about Santa never hurt me, so I'm choosing not to lie to them either.
Before the arrival of our first child, our views were much the same. Real life, though, has a way of shattering one's preconceptions in the area of child rearing. You'll keep us posted?
Steve